The Howlers: Most Controversial Umpiring Decisions in IPL History

Since its inception in 2008, the Indian Premier League (IPL) has been a rollercoaster ride of exhilarating cricket moments and nail-biting finishes. Yet, amidst the excitement, there have been instances that left players, fans, and pundits scratching their heads in disbelief. Umpiring decisions, often at the center of heated debates, have sparked controversies that continue to resonate in the annals of IPL history.

Ashes to Ashes, Dust to Dust: The Umpire’s Call

In the realm of LBW decisions, the infamous ‘umpire’s call’ has stirred its fair share of controversy. One such incident unfolded during the 2019 IPL final between Mumbai Indians (MI) and Chennai Super Kings (CSK). In a critical juncture of the match, umpire Gaffaney adjudged CSK’s captain MS Dhoni LBW to Jasprit Bumrah’s delivery, despite replays indicating the ball marginally missing the wicket. This decision proved decisive as CSK ultimately succumbed to defeat, relinquishing the IPL trophy.

Read more:- The IPL Umpire: A Symbol of Sportsmanship and Fair Play

Dhoni’s Run Out: A Question of Grounding

The 2012 IPL qualifier between CSK and Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB) witnessed another heart-stopping moment. In a nerve-wracking finale, CSK’s fate rested on MS Dhoni’s shoulders. With the scores level on the last ball, Dhoni attempted a second run but fell short of his crease, triggering a frenzied run-out appeal. Initially ruled not out, replays failed to conclusively establish whether Dhoni’s bat had grounded behind the crease before the bails were dislodged. The match ventured into a nail-biting Super Over, eventually clinched by CSK.

Six or Not Six? The Third Umpire Blunder

In a peculiar turn of events during the 2013 IPL clash between Kings XI Punjab (KXIP) and Rajasthan Royals (RR), David Miller’s apparent six over the long-on boundary was controversially ruled as a four by the third umpire. The decision left spectators bewildered as replays unequivocally confirmed the ball’s trajectory clearing the boundary rope. The incident cast doubts on the competence of officiating officials and underscored the fallibility of human judgment.

Dhoni DRS Drama: The Withdrawn Review

The strategic employment of the Decision Review System (DRS) has been a hallmark of IPL encounters. However, a curious incident unfolded during a 2019 fixture between CSK and Rajasthan Royals (RR). Following an LBW decision against him, CSK’s skipper MS Dhoni opted for a DRS review, only to seemingly rescind his decision upon viewing the replays. However, the review withdrawal protocol thwarted Dhoni’s intentions, culminating in his dismissal and eliciting dismay from CSK faithful.

The Missed No-Ball: Turning Point of the Match?

During the 2021 IPL clash between Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB) and Sunrisers Hyderabad (SRH), a pivotal moment arose in the final over. With RCB requiring 14 runs for victory, Harshal Patel appeared to clinch the match with a towering six. However, the on-field umpire deemed it a no-ball for overstepping, a decision contested by RCB following replays showcasing the bowler’s foot marginally behind the crease. SRH ultimately clinched a narrow victory amidst contentious circumstances.

Find Out More:- IPL commentators are contributing to a fire of controversy in the tournament.

The Howlers: More Controversial Umpiring Decisions in IPL History 

As the IPL saga unfolds, additional umpiring controversies have emerged, perpetuating spirited debates:

1. Short Run Steals the Show: A critical short-run call was overlooked during the thrilling 2020 encounter between Delhi Capitals (DC) and Punjab Kings (PBKS), casting doubt on the integrity of the result.
2. Jadeja’s Six or No Six? The On-Field Confusion:** Ravindra Jadeja’s controversial six in the 2019 CSK vs. RR clash underscored the need for clearer communication between on-field and third umpires.
3. Virat Kohli’s Furious Exit: The Inside Edge Debate:** Virat Kohli’s contentious LBW dismissal in the 2022 season reignited discussions on the accuracy of on-field umpires and the efficacy of DRS technology.
4. Dhoni Loses Cool: The Pressure Cooker Situation:** MS Dhoni’s uncharacteristic outburst during a 2019 match highlighted the immense pressure players face and the potential for umpiring errors to escalate tensions.
5. Missed Catches and Bails Flying: The Human Error Factor:** Human errors, such as missed catches and bails flying off without dislodging the stumps, underscore the need for enhanced training and officiating standards.

These controversies underscore the perpetual quest for flawless umpiring in the IPL’s electrifying atmosphere. While technological interventions like DRS have enhanced decision-making, the specter of human error persists, necessitating continual improvement in officiating standards. Despite the controversies, the IPL remains a testament to cricket’s enduring allure, where every decision holds the power to shape destinies and ignite passions.