The Hardik Pandya captaincy test: Will it work in Mumbai’s favour?

Hardik Pandya (Source: Twitter)

The Indian Premier League(IPL) 2024 is not far away from the beginning. The fans will be looking forward to another thrilling T20 franchise tournament full of surprises. With expectations high, there have also been some surprising returns and big changes. It is safe to say that this has increased the amount of attention from the fans, who hope these changes will also lead to some great performances. This can either be a game-changing or destructive decision based on the results.

One major change in a franchise team that has been talked about is the Mumbai Indians. After 11 years the 5-time champions will be playing under a new skipper in Hardik Pandya, who has been traded into the team. There has already been a lot of disagreement between the Paltan fans regarding this topic. After all, filling the shoes of Rohit Sharma is not going to be easy as well. There has already been a lot of controversy regarding this decision. All eyes will be on the swashbuckling all-rounder going into the season.

The Hardik Pandya captaincy is currently one of the biggest topics going forward. The drama will also be set since Hardik will be leading the franchise against his former team Gujarat Titans in the opening game in Ahmedabad. However, even with the negative media around this decision, it still does not seem like the people hate Hardik Pandya it is the way the change in leadership was made.

Let us look at the positives and negatives of this decision:

Positives

Let us first be clear that this is not the first time Hardik is playing for this franchise. He has been a major part of the team in the last 4 title wins for the Mumbai Indians, and he has got great history with most of the senior players. If we take a look at his captaincy record, he has been successful even in his short stint in international cricket. With a win rate of over 60% in all the formats he has led his team in, including a relatively new side in Gujarat Titans with a title and runner-up in the first two seasons. With this record, we can see that it might not be the worst decision in giving the reins to Hardik in the upcoming season at all. Hardik has been one of the most talented all-rounders in the IPL, who is capable of winning games single-handedly with his explosive batting and handy spells with the ball. This has given the team extra depth going into the season.

Negatives

There is no doubt about Hardik’s capabilities as a player and skipper, but looking at the last few months, we cannot surely expect him to be at his best straight away. Hardik has not played a lot of cricket since the 2023 World Cup game vs Bangladesh where he suffered an ankle injury. There have been a fair amount of fitness issues with him in the past as well, which could affect the dynamics of the team. We also have to look into the matter that the fans might not be behind him going into the tournament. Dealing with the negativity surrounding him will be a major challenge. The circumstances going into this season have not been absolutely sweet and savoury for the 30-year-old superstar.

Verdict

If we look at the circumstances leading up to this decision and the reactions, this might not look like the right thing to do, but we still cannot forget the success rate of the individual as well. The love for Rohit Sharma might play a factor, in some people not accepting him at all in the long race. Overall, it might be a case where these reactions are based on emotions rather than the ability of the player. It also might be a case where maybe the change should have come a bit later since Rohit has still been having a great run as the captain. We still cannot ignore the fact that Hardik Pandya has proven himself as a player and a leader in his career already. Therefore, we should be giving him a chance this season going forward. It will still be one of his biggest challenges, where Hardik will not only have to handle situations on the field but off the field as well for millions of fans to witness. Whether he will succeed or not, will be seen in the upcoming IPL 2024, where the real drama and excitement will take place.